Understanding West Coast Transit: A Case Study

Public Administration // Understanding West Coast Transit: A Case Study

Author’s Name

Institutional Affiliation

Understanding West Coast Transit: A Case Study

Effective teamwork drives members to fulfill the tasks and succeed. It is this teamwork that allows members to have a combined action to work together toward the same goals. In spite of resentment and rancor between members, effective leaders can achieve their goals. In other words, collaboration and teamwork can thrive in the process of accomplishing tasks. However, collaboration and teamwork necessitate a blend of communication, interpersonal, and problem-solving skills so that team members can work together towards the joint goals (Jaques, 2017). If this situation happens, the team members can perceive the potential value in working together. Additionally, this capability to complete the tasks while working together materializes if leaders impart some mutual benefits. There can be meaningful reasons for the team members to work together if their leaders offer awards, incentives, and other rewarding perks to the members’ advantage. Since collaboration and teamwork emphasize equal opportunities and tasks, team members can prosper if they manage to communicate ideas and to participate in the tasks.

The three criteria for evaluating effective teams fall under a) member satisfaction, b) task performance, and c) team viability. Of course, effective leaders need to discover some ways to improve the relationships of the team members to strengthen their collaboration conditions (Tuckman & Jensen, 2010, p. 46). Once these leaders find techniques to augment efficiency, they can enthuse innovation, preserve these persons to be structured, ask them to express their sentiments, enforce active task management practices, embolden open communication, and make their interests parallel. Conversely, Bernie Hollis’ and Pete Denson’s team seems to be effective if they provide benefits for the managers, namely Lea Jing, Jon Mahonney, and Katarina Tanney. Based on this reading material, Bernie Hollis’ and Pete Denson’s team faces numerous problems. For example, these managers and employees do not want to participate in the tasks since they will receive salaries for the assigned tasks. When Tanney gives her comment that the project does not materialize since none gets paid to do the tasks, problems grow within the team. To resolve these problems, Bernie Hollis and Pete Denson have to consider some of the problems to achieve a dependable result.

This first problem brings a big impact on the company’s agenda to thrive in the market. The second problem falls under the significant amounts of unpaid overtime to complete the project before the deadline. This unpaid overtime adds an extra burden for Tanney due to her personal problems. She cannot work overtime due to her counseling sessions. As a leader, Pete Denson fails to communicate his objectives to express his business agenda since he does not even ask the Vice President of Marketing, Bernie Hollis, why these managers will not receive proper compensation when the project budget is adequate. He also nosedives when he does not set the project goals and the requirements to fulfill the tasks. As well, the third problem of the team comes from Pete Denson’s attitude and behavior. When Denson hears negative comments from other managers, he becomes frustrated. He responds to these adverse reactions by saying that all have complaints, issues, and problems. When further asks if there are further complaints, Tanney reacts that her personal issues and counseling sessions are not complaints and that she does not want to work with Denson anymore unless he apologizes and promises to give her respect. These circumstances fuel up that make Bernie Hollis’ and Pete Denson’s team become impossible to form alliances and build trusts. In other words, the “team” gathered by Bernie Hollis and Pete Denson is effective. Bernie Hollis and Pete Denson forget to consider these criteria, such as team viability, task performance, and member satisfaction to complete the last-minute projects. In the end, Bernie Hollis and Pete Denson succeed to have a good team if they make a clear and convincing cause, converse prospects, institute team objectives, influence team-member strong points, foster unity between team adherents, inspire progress, and the like.

Tuckman’s five stages of group formation help Bernie Hollis and Pete Denson identify the stages of team development.

a) In the Forming Stage, Pete Denson brings the team together to discuss the agenda and review necessary issues before they proceed to the tasks. In this stage, he needs to evaluate the company’s current situations and demands for growth and innovation. Since the company assigns this project to Denson, he can persuade others to help him work together by saying that “we have been asked to complete these tasks” (Grand Canyon University, 2019).

b) In the Storming Stage, Denson leads the meeting and discourse possible plans and project scenarios to complete immediately. By setting goals beforehand and by acknowledging the potential issues, Denson can proceed to do the tasks step by step. There may be issues going on in the meeting, but team members, such as Tanney and Jing can comply with the demands without hurting their feelings. For example, Denson operates his agenda within office hours and finishes the meeting before the start of Tanney counseling periods. He can accomplish it by not sacrificing others personal issues as long as he has transparent objectives on what to do. If brainstorming is necessary, he can do it with them during office hours. Working overtime may be helpful if additional time is necessary; however, Denson can finish the meeting, planning, and reviewing within the allotted time. The fact the project budget is adequate, Denson can offer some incentives and benefits for those who work overtime. For example, Tanney as a manager can also assign her best members to do the tasks overtime while she is away so there will be no time to waste. If Denson does this at the start of the project meeting, he does not anymore face problems with other managers.

c) In the Norming Stage, Denson’s team members will recognize him as a good leader. Effective leaders acknowledge members’ issues and problems while keeping them on track. If Denson does not strike first about Tanney’s personal issues as complaints, he does not have any problem by now. However, he can change the turn of events if he learns to recognize Tanney’s issues and moves forward to fulfill the project. By moving forward, Denson has to initiate another plan to do the tasks closely. He needs to convince his team members, who are managers, to help him communicate the projects to their subordinates to work overtime to accomplish the projects by receiving incentives.

d) In the Performing Stage, Jon Mahonney acknowledges the importance of the new project to help Denson make the things possible. This situation adds to the spirit of the team in which Denson needs to have. At least, he has a volunteer to help perform the task. Though the tasks demand effort and motivation, Mahonney steps out and facilitates the project by convincing Tanney and Jing to finish the project. Based on some of the textbook reading, Denson’s roles are to encourage his team members to complete the tasks by acknowledging their issues and personal baggage and by planning cautiously without hurting others’ feelings. He needs to realize that his team members must recognize the types of the task they are doing.

Schein’s highlighted three behavioral profile roles are objective thinker, receptive helper, and strong battler. Based on the reading material, Lea Jing represents to be the objective thinker. She observes and makes things right when it does. She is discreet and perceptive during the dialog. She only speaks when she needs to do it. Also, Denson seems to be a strong battler. He has to deal with the team. He may display some aggressive acts when people start questioning concerns. When he points out that Tanney complaints about her situations like the counseling sessions to interpret it as complaints, he becomes a strong battler. However, the receptive helper offers amazing support for others and becomes an optimistic member of a group (Schein, 1996, p. 14). Jon Mahonney appears to be a friendly helper who speaks to ease pressures and tensions. He knows when to calm the situations down when all people reach the peak of their anger. When it happens, he interpolates and asks others to make things happen. Upon knowing the three behavioral profile roles, business leaders must understand them to have good and effective relationships with the objective thinker, the responsive helper, and the strong battler (Schein, 1996, p. 18). Perhaps, communication skills are important. Among the managers or participants in the case, Jon Mahonney represents his effective communication strategies. Denson must have these skills, too, in order to eliminate conflicts and misunderstanding. If Denson initiates his ideas and his goals beforehand by articulating his goals, he can convince Tanney and Jing to help him thrive in the project.

According to the textbook, Organizational Behavior, the two main types of conflict are internal and external. Basically, two conflicts arise in situations. To mean internal conflicts suggests the presence of issues and misinterpretation between Denson and team members. About external conflicts, Denson’s team faces the last-minute project in which all must confront the strain and pressure. In this case, it is correct to propose that Denson must manage the conflict, in this case, using one direct conflict management and one indirect conflict management approach. For example, he has to face the problem by acknowledging the potential issues of the team members and by lowering the tenors of their voices. Of course, Denson needs to provide one specific task leadership activity that persuades team members to perform their tasks and one specific maintenance activity that encourages them to work throughout the completion of the project by giving them incentives and rewards. Moreover, Denson’s most significant disruptive behavior must be changed. He must be apologetic and respectful. In difficult situations, Denson nosedives to offer Jing, Mahonney, and Tanney a workable and viable workplace. Of course, Denson must know how to motivate each person. Perhaps, incentives and recognition work better to convince people to perform the tasks. Denson knows Maslow’s Hierarchy theory of needs and others when dealing with team members. Other experts know the importance of reinforcement strategies for people to operate and perform the assigned projects. In general, Denson needs to see these things as essential elements of success.

References

Grand Canyon University. (2019). West Coast Transit Case Study. Grand Canyon University: Word Document.

Jaques, E. (2017). Requisite organization: A total system for effective managerial organization and managerial leadership for the 21st century. New York, NY: Routledge.

Schein, E. H. (1996). Three cultures of management: The key to organizational learning. Sloan Management Review, 38(1), 9-20.

Tuckman, B. W., & Jensen, M. A. C. (2010). Stages of small-group development revisited. Group Facilitation: A Research & Applications Journal, 10, 43-48.

2019/5604

Author: admin