Offering a Cutting Commissaries Report

Accounting // Offering a Cutting Commissaries Report

Offering a Cutting Commissaries Report

Author’s Name

Institutional Affiliation

Offering a Cutting Commissaries Report

Question 6: Comparison of Option 1 with the Preferred Method under Option 2

The Department of Defense (DOD) under Option 1 showed 154 domestic commissaries. Sixty-seven transnational commissaries, however, stayed operational “to all military personnel, who did not have any contact to the rudimentary American products” (Hansen, Pizzini, & Brien, 2018, p. 1). If the United States regime jettisoned domestic – the non-distant commissaries, the Defense Commissary Agency projected that it would diminish central operating expenditures. The reduction of these operating expenses occurred due to the dismissal of the store managers, logistics hubs, and their related costs. Under Option 1, DeCA Center of Operations in Fort Lee, for example, would annex its support for the 22 distant commissaries that would be liable for collecting the grocery voucher program (Hansen, Pizzini, & Brien, 2018, p. 3). With the reduction of domestic commissaries, the net cost of operations was high. Under Option 2, DeCA would only remove “a subset of 154 domestic stores” (Hansen, Pizzini, & Brien, 2018, p. 3). Therefore, the Department of Defense (DOD) under Option 1 would impact on the lives of the active-duty personnel, such as the reserve and guard members of the Uniformed Services, the retirees of these services, the authorized family members, the DOD civilian workers overseas, and other official groups.

That decision of closing the domestic commissaries would impact on the active-duty personnel, retirees, and more. This judgment would contrast between Option 1 and Option 2. Option 1 emphasized that “the far-flung and sequestered commissaries would stay open” (Hansen, Pizzini, & Brien, 2018, p. 3). The closure of the inland commissaries might be a good idea; however, the isolated and distant stores should be available for the concerned individuals. DeCA assessed that “it would decrease its employees enough to attain a ten-percent discount (10%) in central operating costs” (Hansen, Pizzini, & Brien, 2018, p. 3). Under Option 2, DeCA decided to pinpoint its services in view of its 20-mile radius to rank its DeCA based on the amount of service delivery (Hansen, Pizzini, & Brien, 2018, p. 3). When the stores grew lowest-ranked, DeCA would close its operations. This condition would affect the quality of lives of the people of the active-duty staff members, such as the reserve and guard members of the Uniformed Services, the retirees of these services, the legal family members, the DOD civilian employees overseas, and other official groups. Under Option 2, the complexity of directing the new program should be clarified through new guidelines and policies.

The closures of numerous commissaries produced a negative impact on active-duty military personnel, DeCA employees, retirees, and the like. Firstly, the closure of commissaries would cut a number of services among military recruits, DeCA personnel, retirees, and more. Secondly, a number of personnel, such as store administrators, workforces for the logistics hubs, and other related personnel would lose their jobs. Moreover, the closure of a number of stores would offer additional problem on people in distant places. If the United States government chose to close commissaries including the distant and remote areas, many of the clients and patrons would find it hard to access to commissary products.

Question 7: The Eligibility of the Shoppers

There have been a number of active-duty personnel who are eligible for the shopping spree. The reserve and guard members of the Uniformed Services, the pensioners of the services, the certified family members, the DOD noncombatant labors overseas, and approved groups would be eligible shoppers who got affected by the ending of the domestic commissaries. Firstly, the reserve and guard members of the Uniformed Services, the pensioners of the services, the certified family members, the DOD noncombatant labors overseas, and approved groups could not get big discounts if they buy products and services in the private stores (Jones, 2016, p. 46). Secondly, they could not directly get access to the products in the commissaries. Thirdly and lastly, the commissaries remain the only grocery stores for the military personnel. Congress would likely consider military welfare. According to Hansen, Pizzini, and Brien (2018), Congress ratified the act of appropriation, such as the automatic, inclusive budget slashes. If Congress became unsuccessful to come to a reasonable arrangement, it would reduce its budget for the commissaries (Hansen, Pizzini, & Brien, 2018, p. 3). In this case, DeCA commissioners would decrease the net cost of processes. To review, the first option was to remove consistent national commissaries. What happened next was that this military personnel would receive food vouchers to be used for cost-effective grocery stores. The second option would keep the U.S. commissary system mostly complete and preemptively nearby commissaries to offer rationally priced products (Hansen, Pizzini, & Brien, 2018, p. 4). Congress would choose Option 1 since military personnel has the options to purchase products at the commissaries. It would prefer Option 1 in order to serve the reserve and guard members of the Uniformed Services, the pensioners of the services, the certified family members, the DOD noncombatant labors overseas, and approved groups in the remote and international posts.

Finally, cutting commissaries in the domestic areas would be appropriate rather than cutting the budget in the distant and international regions. Congress, if it failed to reach its budget, should choose Option 1 to stop domestic commissaries. Since the domestic areas have had alternative stores from the private, the United States government via DeCA should decide to end its services (Jones, 2016, p. 46). However, it should not end all international and remote U.S. locations since these commissaries played an important role in the welfare of military personnel. In the end, DeCA administrators should choose Option 1 including the net cost of processes.

References

Hansen, S., Pizzini, M., & Brien, S. (2018). Cutting commissaries: Approaches to downsizing a government program. Institute of Management Accountants Case Journal, Vol. 11, No. 2, Article 2, pp. 1-6.

Jones, D. M. (2016). Downsizing the Federal Government: Management of Public Sector Workforce Reductions: Management of Public Sector Workforce Reductions. New York, NY: Routledge.

2019/1032

Author: admin