Philosophy Paper

Philosophy // Philosophy Paper

Abstract

Hobbes or Rousseau, we must all strike a balance.

This paper delves into two differing philosophies on politics and life itself. Hobbes espouses a mechanical, scientific view of how to lead a country while Rousseau believes we are fine the way we have been formed by nature.

Ironically, both have died of stroke and yet their views differ dramatically. In today’s world there is a crisis. A crisis of hope on how to lead life. Democracy is at a critical risk but the fight must go on.

Hobbes and Rousseau

Between Hobbes and Rousseau, the idea of nature vastly differ. Perhaps this is due to the times. Hobbes was born to a war torn England against the Irish and threats of a civil war while Rosseau lived at a time of peace although he  didn’t approve the administration of the government of the time and built the foundations for a French Revolution which would topple the monarchy and grant power to the people rather than the few rich people on the monarchy.

Hobbes believed in the power of the sovereign because he thought that otherwise, there would be chaos. He believed that man by nature are brutish, violent and selfish therefore should be shackled to the rule of one law that would unite them.

This law is the social contract wherein man shall follow to uphold the sophistication of being led by a wise ruler. He thought otherwise man would tear each other apart in the self-motivating force to grant themselves more than the other.

On the other hand, Rousseau believed that man is by nature a good person. He is innocent and kind thus deserves to be free to decide his fate in life without the shackles of a few monarchies who aggrandize themselves and are indeed corrupt.

He was a man who led a solitary life in the provinces and wrote books while doing botany in the afternoons. He loved nature and the natural way life has its way of being ingeniously correct in following his own instincts

He was thought to have committed suicide for he was a bit mentally unhinged and thought people were against him. He was buried next to Voltaire, another revolutionary, in the cemetery.

He was responsible for the beautiful belief in humankind as a foundation for democracy which spread towards the Americas.

Hobbes, despite his acknowledgement of sovereignty was alienated by the church because he did not believe in them.

He thought in terms of science and was in fact prone to believe that everything can be attributed to a certain mechanism in nature. He believed in the theory of deduction whereby he can deduce things by observing the subject matter and deducing it to its plainest manner.

In this way he was a scientific political theorist.

Hobbes wrote the famous novel The Leviathan wherein he believed that sovereignty is the key to the successful peace he so wanted for his country.

The Leviathan is a Jewish mythological creature from the sea monster whose value cannot be ascertained whether to have come from God or the Devil. I have seen a cover of the book with the monster rising from the ocean with a staff of sovereignty in one of his hands.

Between Hobbes and Rousseau I am more partial to Rousseau because I am a democrat and I believe that people are indeed innately good given that they be free from the shackles of sovereignty.

I have recently watched a movie about Queen Anne, The Favourite and have seen the corruption, the indecency of a sole monarch leading the nation. She was ill and therefore not so free to rule the land to which was taken advantage of by her favorite Lady in waiting who seduced her to follow her command only to be upended by another Lady in Waiting with equal ambitions to seduce the Queen. It is a very startling film which shows how, when a few are able to rule the land with their ruckus pedantry can lead to some very twisted ways of handling power.

In a democratic society, these secretive corruptions would not do. A president would sit to preside over his governing body who will listen to the people instead of letting the President own a large portion of power. Power comes from the people who vote and choose who will lead them in the Senate and Congress and who are to be trusted to follow what is good for the people, the masses. That is the democratic society I dream of.

Rousseau spent his life in rich solitude writing about Emile a boy whose education was at first structured but later on he was free to be what he wanted. Even though, Rousseau believed in the passive role of women, he did espouse that women not be thwarted but allowed to learn how to read, write, do math and know the social graces of the time. She is free to be educated as befits a lady, though, I can forgive him that, given that the times were less kind to women and he delivers a message to women of the future, that they are not to be thwarted but allowed to grow as natural as they choose to become.

Hobbes views man as machines. This, I disagree with and can only be the source of explanation why slavery was espoused by his country thinking people are mechanical creatures who follow blindly the laws of the land by a few sovereign parties who lead the land and relish its fruit without apportioning it rightly with the people.

Hobbes must have overlooked the consequence of his theories but then again, we are always evolving and we can only forgive him for thinking such. If he triumphed and had his way, there would not be a governing body to lead England whose hand is not under the sovereign Queen Elizabeth anymore but upon Prime Minister Theresa May. There is a certain relief that the old system is not so strictly partial to a few deemed sovereign or the chosen ones. This is a fallacy that certain people are born to lead the land. I believe that the people should choose their ruler because the ruler supports them. I have nothing against the Queen of England but as Princess Diana has proven, they are human given to human follies like all of us and therefore may or may not be fit to lead a nation.

“For Hobbes political authority is artificial” (Thomas Hobbes:Moral and Political Philosophy) He espouses the artificial part of the people, to be unnatural is to reach for that strong will to lead the people. The very though of an artificial ruler devoid of his natural senses is unattainable and may even twist things to abnormality. There would be secrecies in the sovereignty, murders, scandals, corruption because even the sovereign people are fallible.

: “He argues that human beings are not naturally social or political, that the state of nature is a state of war, and that we must self-consciously create a government that is based on mutual consent and that presupposes a fundamental equality among its members.” (An Introduction to the Works of Hobbes).

This is too idealistic. To believe that equality will be achieved by the mutual consent to abide by a ruler. Unlike Rousseau he thinks man is constantly in a state of war. It must have been the times he was living through at that time when civil war was about to break out and he can observe that what is needed is a strong ruler. But even rulers are fallible.

“State of nature in Hobbes philosophy was not a good place to spend a weekend at. Firstly, only to do a resume, we define state of nature the pre-contractual society. In this state, Hobbes believes that men are involved in a never ending free for all war, where the strongest, or smartest, wants to survive and outlive the weakest, or dumbest. In this state, there are no laws or codes, anyone can kill you or take advantage of you if you let them. Men want always more, men are conatus, a latin term which means “crave for”. And they crave for goods, for power, for selfish accomplishment and improvement, even if this means hard times for others.”(Celi, 2016)

This is a grim and aggressive attack on Hobbes theory on the nature of man. If this were so and Hobbes did succeed in his establishment of his theory then things would have gone offhand. We would have gone back to a barbaric society.

“The Social Contract has provided radicals and revolutionaries with key themes since it was published. Yet Rousseau can be presented at the same time as deeply individualist, and as controlling and pandering to popularist totalitarianism. In psychology he looked to stage theory and essentialist notions concerning the sexes (both of which continue to plague us) yet did bring out the significance of difference and of the impact of the environment. In life he was difficult he was difficult to be around, and had problems relating to others, yet he gave glimpses of a rare connectedness.”(Jean Jaques Rousseau on nature, wholeness and education)

It is ironic that Rousseau could be so solitary and yet espoused social democracy in all forms. Perhaps in one of his walks and reveries he found the seed of humanity from which we can all accept ourselves for our own selves and not be so heavy on ourselves.

His theories are forgiving of all our follies, there is nothing wrong with us as humans, we err, we do good but basically, we are good people. Humans, allowed to be free, grow to develop and find their own way in life and usually they hold the key to evolution, which is the development of our society.

“Thinking about Romanticism means emotion, thinking about Enlightenment means almost completely the opposite: reason. Was the way people thought about nature in those respective periods indeed this distinct? In this article Heikki Mikkeli writes about the view on nature in the period of the Enlightenment and Romanticism” (Mikkeli).

Romanticism is about love, that which is a force of nature and goes against reason because it is a reason upon itself. It happens and we cannot do anything about unless we rationally avoid it. The distinction is extreme and striking. Are we to forget ourselves and leave caution to the wind and be blinded by love or shake yourself up to the realities of life. Perhaps there is a balance to be struck between passion and patience. Perhaps even today we still debate among ourselves how much emotion should we allow ourselves to get into and how much is enough and to be rational about love.

These days, love can be cured like a disease by going to a psychiatrist and being prescribed medicine for unrequited love. Or there are travel tours that distract you or may even make the pain of not being with your loved one much more distinct.

However it may be, balance may be the key.

While government and law provide for the security and well-being of people in their collective life, the sciences, letters, and arts — less despotic though perhaps more powerful — wrap garlands of flowers around the chains that weigh people down. … Need erected thrones, and the sciences and arts consolidated them.

To Rousseau, the age represented a “loathsome and deceptive conformity.” Contrary to a notion of progress, “all minds seem to have been cast in the same mold. We no longer dare to appear as we really are” but constitute “the herd known as society.”(Rousseau on solitary Human Nature).

This is the sad fact

And yet sometimes, despotic societies have this deeply ingrained in their system for countries with despotic rulers, A revolution is around the corner.

“ The book also advances an original interpretation of Rousseau’s political philosophy, emerging from this encounter with Hobbesian ideas and arguments. This stresses the importance and interplay of three themes: first, nature understood as a normative standard; second, free will as an inalienable gift of nature; third, the role of the passions in general and of amour-propre in particular.” (Douglass). 

There are people who thrive on love and love alone. I salute them.

References:

An Introduction to the Work of Hobbes, Great Thinkers, Retrieved from https://thegreatthinkers.org/hobbes/introduction/

Celi, 2018, What is the State of Nature According To Hobbes, Quora, Retrieved from https://www.quora.com/What-is-the-state-of-nature-according-to-Hobbes

Douglass, Rousseau and Hobbes: Nature, Free Will and the Passions Retrieved from

http://www.oxfordscholarship.com/view/10.1093/acprof:oso/9780198724964.001.0001/acprof-9780198724964

Mikkeli, Back to Nature, Retrieved from file:///C:/Users/dylan%20aranas/Downloads/17770-19676-1-PB%20(2).pdf

Jean Jaques Rousseau on Nature, Wholeness and Education, infed, Retrieved from http://infed.org/mobi/jean-jacques-rousseau-on-nature-wholeness-and-education/

Rousseau on Solitary Human Nature, Hermitage, Retrieved from https://www.hermitary.com/solitude/rousseau-nature.html

Thomas Hobbes, Moral and Political Philosophy, Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy, Retrieved from https://www.iep.utm.edu/hobmoral/

2019/1027

Author: admin